National Standards

I am an angry camper. Well technically speaking I’m an angry teacher.

I’m angry with politicians and I’m particularly angry with the media who are now just seem to be working as PR types for the politicians (You know who you are John Hartevelt). Here are my main points.

Firstly, why are teachers no longer considered a body of professionals capable of using their extensive body of knowledge gained from years of training and experience? Instead you think we are a bunch of moaners resistant to change. Do you not think we have the right to express our concerns at policies that are, in our professional experience, will impact negatively on the education of New Zealand children?

Put it this way… if the government decided to bring in national standards for health and then linked the pay of physicians to the death-rates of their patients, there would be uproar. Any whitey-righties reading this will say, “that’s a ridiculous notion” and bluster away tut-tutting me for my nonsense while saying some of their best golfing partners are doctors and death rates are arbitrary, Boon. They are affected by all manner of things. My point here is national standards are also an arbitrary measure of a child’s performance at one moment in time. It can be affected my a range of things like poverty, hunger, tiredness, mood, poverty, absence from school and poverty. To link my pay to that measure of performance is totally unfair. In fact, Hekia Parata, I would like to link your pay to your performance, which I shall measure by bouncing a basketball up and down. The more I bounce it, the more you get paid.

I’d also like to know why are the media still not continuing to ask why we are adopting systems that has worked so well for the United States and United Kingdom they are ranked 10 and 16 places behind us on the OECD rankings (2010) . We are 4th on that list by the way. The reason I’ve included it is because the Guardian has an easy-to-read summary on their website, and it dates back to a time when National were putting the standards in place. UK and US schools teach the test to their kids to boost their national standard league table position and regularly exclude students that fall below the line. This also bumps up their statistics.

Another point I need to make is about the motivations of each group arguing in favour of national standards. Politicians are motivated by votes. The more votes you get, the better chance you have of running the country. You cannot tell me that this is not the case across the board. Labour, National, Greens, everyone. I know it’s the case because politicians never say anything. At the moment, anything they say they can’t remember later. Or they never read it. David Shearer did say they other day that he wasn’t going to cancel the national standards if Labour led the next government. He is doing this because he knows there are votes available. If agrees with them, keep them. If he doesn’t, dump them. Don’t snag yourself on the top of the fence not saying anything. Be a man!

On the other hand, newspapers are motivated by selling papers, or more recently, directing internet traffic to their websites. The more people who buy their paper, the more money they get. The press – mainly (fairfax), but also Granny – will tell you they are motivated by some altruistic notion of keeping parents informed. They are not. They want to sell papers (increase web traffic).

A reader pointed out in The Press newspaper yesterday they had counted three major changes that had happened to the education sector since they’d left school in the mid-eighties. That’s probably about right. It isn’t very good for job security, or attracting the best and brightest to your profession. But never mind – unregistered teachers will fill the gap.

Even so, it doesn’t matter what anyone does. Whatever system I have to work under, I will. Because it’s not about what I believe in. It’s not about what you believe in either. It’s not about whether I agree or disagree with your politics John Key. It’s about providing the best education I can to the children I am educating this year. Do what you like to the system you misguided ideologue, but I’m not going to let it impact on the quality education my class gets.

See you next time.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s